Reviews for Eternal
Booklist Reviews 2009 February #1
Set in the same alternate world as Tantalize (2007), this companion novel is a witty, dark love story of death and redemption. Miranda dreams of one day being a star, but she s already captured the heart of one fan: her lifelong guardian angel Zachary. When he sees her death approach, he desperately breaks the rules to prevent it, an act that dooms both of their souls: Zachary is cast out of Heaven, and Miranda lives long enough to be made a vampire. A year later, Miranda has settled into her wicked life as the glamorous daughter of the vampire king, and Zachary has been sent to their estate on a mission that may earn back his wings. Forced to confront the monster Miranda has become, Zachary is determined to save her soul and redeem them both. Smith s take on aristocratic vampire society is a sometimes humorous, sometimes horrible mix of the niceties of high society and the blasť violence of monsters, while angels appear to be a largely bureaucratic organization. Miranda and Zachary are complex, sympathetic characters, and their hopeful ending is well-earned. Copyright 2009 Booklist Reviews.
Booklist Reviews 2009 February #2
Set in the same alternate world as Tantalize (2007), this companion novel is a witty, dark love story of death and redemption. Miranda dreams of one day being a star, but she s already captured the heart of one fan: her lifelong guardian angel Zachary. When he sees her death approach, he desperately breaks the rules to prevent it, an act that dooms both of their souls: Zachary is cast out of Heaven, and Miranda lives long enough to be made a vampire. A year later, Miranda has settled into her wicked life as the glamorous daughter of the vampire king, and Zachary has been sent to their estate on a mission that may earn back his wings. Forced to confront the monster Miranda has become, Zachary is determined to save her soul and redeem them both. Smith s take on aristocratic vampire society is a sometimes humorous, sometimes horrible mix of the niceties of high society and the blasť violence of monsters, while angels appear to be a largely bureaucratic organization. Miranda and Zachary are complex, sympathetic characters, and their hopeful ending is well earned. Copyright 2009 Booklist Reviews.
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2013 Fall
He's her fallen guardian angel, she's vampire royalty, and they're in love--but can that save Miranda's soul? This graphic adaptation of the acclaimed novel by the same name is told from Zachary's perspective yet shows the inner struggle of both Miranda and Zachary to be good. Doyle's traditional graphic novel style black-and-white illustrations ultimately add little to the story.
Horn Book Magazine Reviews 2009 #2
Teen readers have lapped up the steady outpouring of vampire books, most of which feature a forbidden mortal/immortal romance. Here Smith creatively revamps the star-crossed pair as a "newly risen" eternal (read vampire), adolescent Miranda, and her fallen guardian angel, Zachary. Chosen by the current Dracula himself to be his princess and heir, Miranda spends her nights receiving visitors, performing bloody executions, and dressing up for "Father." To earn back his wings, Zachary applies for the job of Miranda's personal assistant. The kitsch factor is high: Miranda notes of her high-end sleeping coffin, "We saved seventy percent by ordering online." But, like the author's delectably demonic Tantalize (rev. 3/07), Eternal is not for the squeamish: Miranda accepts the gruesome practices of castle life (draining blood from semi-starved teens in chains) as wholly as she takes to her new designer clothes and maid service. The suspenseful and entertaining story plays out in a parallel Chicago mingling mortal and immortal, damned and blessed. When the beautiful Zachary awakens the vestiges of Miranda's humanity, together they raise a full-scale supernatural battle against the increasingly unstable Master. Redemption does not come easily, however, and happily-ever-after eludes the couple -- at least for now. An author's note promises a union of the casts of both Tantalize and Eternal in a forthcoming book. This thirsty reader awaits the refill. Copyright 2009 Horn Book Magazine Reviews.
Kirkus Reviews 2009 January #2
Plain Miranda ascends to the rank of vampire princess in this imaginative but somewhat underdeveloped horror-comedy. Revisiting the same world in which bloodsuckers and animal shape-shifters exist alongside and in full view of mortals that was the setting of Smith's 2007 novel Tantalize, the locale has changed from Austin to Chicago. Additionally, guardian angels become part of the cast, providing a rather sardonic love interest for this offering's protagonist in the form of Zachary, who falls from grace while attempting to rescue Miranda from a vampire attacker. In order to save her and himself, he infiltrates the house of Dracul, where Miranda now lives as an unwitting accomplice to the head vampire's grisly schemes. Focusing on the aesthetics of the castle and on the A-list monster world that Miranda now inhabits, Smith falters a bit as she increasingly relies on descriptions of the setting and campy dialogue instead of fleshing out her characters. Still, the pace of this entertaining romp is quick and the action plentiful--a painless, if not particularly memorable, read. (Horror. 14 & up) Copyright Kirkus 2009 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2009 March #3
Smith's latest revisits the dark alternate world of Tantalize (2007) with a new set of characters. Despite the efforts of Zachary, her guardian angel, Dallas teenager Miranda joins the ranks of the undead as an "eternal" (vampire), courtesy of the current Dracula, their aristocratic ruler. A year passes, and as Dracula's pursuit of power begins to affect his sanity, Miranda struggles to acclimate to her new regal life in Dracula's castle (in Chicago). Meanwhile, Zachary has been cast from heaven for revealing his angelic nature while trying to save Miranda, so he poses as a human--and Miranda's personal assistant--trying to save her. Smith balances the story's bloody details with frequent touches of humor (when Zachary is taken aback by Miranda's enormous SUV, she replies, "We're eternals.... We are evil. We are not fuel efficient"). The confessional style, alternating between Miranda and Zachary's points of view, is intriguing as a diary--readers should be hooked by this fully formed world, up through the action-packed finale. Ages 14-up. (Feb.) [Page 63]. Copyright 2009 Reed Business Information.
School Library Journal Reviews 2013 May
Gr 9 Up--Whereas Smith's novel Eternal (Candlewick, 2009) focuses on the character of Miranda and her introduction into the culture of the vampires, called "Eternals," this graphic-novel companion depicts the same set of events from the perspective of Zachary, Miranda's depowered guardian angel. Given this forced perspective, the plot and pacing are often confusing because they require knowledge of events that occur in the novel. That this story is formatted as a graphic novel only serves to emphasize these issues, as passages of time are often inexplicable, secondary character motivations are impossible to decipher, and backstory is nonexistent. Doyle's illustrations are the standout feature here. Her black-and-white ink work is detailed and uses shading to provide clear depth. Furthermore, the framing of each illustration helps to provide a cinematic feel, especially through the use of extreme close-up to highlight facial expressions and character reactions. Overall, this graphic novel cannot break free of its shortcomings and often seems to cram as many supernatural tropes into as few pages as possible. Purchase if students are looking for this specific title after reading the novel.--Ryan F. Paulsen, New Rochelle High School, NY [Page 140]. (c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
School Library Journal Reviews 2009 July
Gr 9 Up-This dark romance is told in alternating chapters from the perspectives of 17-year-old Miranda and her guardian angel, Zachary, in an alternate America in which vampires and werewolves exist. Early in the novel, Zachary falls from grace as punishment for materializing in his full radiance in a failed attempt to save Miranda from being bitten by a vampire. The tale resumes a year later with the now-vampire Miranda a revered princess living among vampire royalty and feasting regularly on humans. Zachary, meanwhile, has sunk into a life of aimless debauchery and is resigned to never regaining his wings when an archangel suddenly gives him the opportunity to become Miranda's personal assistant. Determined to save his former ward, with whom he has fallen in love, Zachary takes the job. Miranda finds herself drawn to him, and the murders she has carelessly committed begin to weigh on her conscience. With his help, she is determined to find a way to redeem herself and help him return to grace. The plot is occasionally choppy and frequently grisly, and the dialogue seems forced in places. Neither Miranda nor Zachary is particularly likable, and the ending, while logical, is not one that romance fans will favor. The story lacks the elegance of Stephenie Meyer's hugely popular novels, but serious vampire buffs will undoubtedly add the novel to their must-read list.-Leah J. Sparks, formerly at Bowie Public Library, MD [Page 92]. Copyright 2008 Reed Business Information.
VOYA Reviews 2009 April
Zachary has been Miranda's guardian angel since birth, but Zachary's care for his charge extends past that of the usual guardian-human connection. In love with "his girl," and unwilling to let any harm befall her, he thwarts fate and averts Miranda's death, only to have her abducted and turned by Dracula himself. Stripped of his wings for his transgression, Zachary is doomed to walk the earth as a fallen angel unless he can rectify his mistake and fulfill one last mission. His task is a difficult one, however, for as an eternal, Miranda is offered everything she never had--fame, fortune, and power. For every day that passes, her old life slips farther away as she embraces her new role as Dracula's cold, cruel princess. Zachary has little time before Miranda is lost completely, and Miranda has very little time before her transformation is complete to recognize the truth of her new life Smith's new novel approaches popular vampire fiction with a new spin: a vampire protagonist who, for most of the book, is as callous as a vampire should be. This darkness serves to illuminate the significance of the struggle between Miranda's human soul and her newly acquired "vampness," but it also reveals new depths of forgiveness, sacrifice, and love. The two characters alternate narration, which further situates the battle between good and evil. Fanpires will not be disappointed with the newest addition to the genre, and the mythology is subtle enough for general fiction readers.--Courtney Huse Wika 4Q 4P J S Copyright 2009 Voya Reviews.